Pwned Passwords

warning

This document hasn't been updated for a few years but I pulled it over from the original BPATTY because I think it has some great info that is hopefully still relevant as far as integrating the Pwned Passwords.

Introduction

In February of 2018, Troy Hunt launched a Pwned Passwords project which made half a billion passwords (hashed with SHA-1) available for download. These passwords were culled from the Anti Public and Exploit.in combo lists and two other large dumps, including:

• The 711 million record Onliner Spambot dump.

• The 1.4B clear text credentials from the "dark web".

Troy and Cloudflare have teamed up to build an API so that enterprises can integrate a k-Anonymity check with their applications and services. For instance, if you wanted to see if the password P@ssw0rd (which has a SHA-1 hash of 21BD12DC183F740EE76F27B78EB39C8AD972A757) exists in Troy's data set, you could make an API call to:

Request URL: https://api.pwnedpasswords.com/range/21BD1

This request will return any hashes with 21BD1 as a prefix, such as:

• (21BD1) 0018A45C4D1DEF81644B54AB7F969B88D65:1 (password "lauragpe")

• (21BD1) 00D4F6E8FA6EECAD2A3AA415EEC418D38EC:2 (password "alexguo029")
• (21BD1) 011053FD0102E94D6AE2F8B83D76FAF94F6:1 (password "BDnd9102")
• (21BD1) 012A7CA357541F0AC487871FEEC1891C49C:2 (password "melobie")
• (21BD1) 0136E006E24E7D152139815FB0FC6A50B15:2 (password "quvekyny")
• ...
• ...

With the results that come back from the API, the enterprise can determine whether or not the full password is present in the results without ever actually having sent the entire password to Troy's API.

Integrating "Pwned Passwords" check into Active Directory password resets

Since the launch of Troy's project there has been a lot of interest in bringing the Pwned Passwords check into the enterprise - particularly with Active Directory. Additionally, a good number of companies want to keep the password checks - even partial SHA-1 hash comparisons - completely within the LAN. At this point in time, there seems to be two primary solutions to accomplish this:

• PwnedPasswordsDLL - open source
• SafePass.me - commercial solution for ~$700

Below is a breakdown of installation instructions and impressions/thoughts on each solution:

Option 1: PwnedPasswordsDLL

Troy tweeted about this solution in late February, and the tweet points to user JacksonVD's blog article which discusses the finer points of compiling his open source DLL. JacksonVD's blog and project page assume the end user has some Visual Studio experience, so I created the following instructions which do not make that assumption.

1. Download Visual Studio Community 2017 from here. You'll also want to install (if they're not selected/installed by default) Desktop development with C++ on the left side, and then on the right side: Windows 8.1 SDK and Windows Universal CRT SDK and Windows 10 SDK (10.0.15063.0).

2. Download JacksonVD's GitHub project by visiting the project page and clicking Clone or Download -> Download Zip and saving the .zip file to your computer. Unzip it to a folder on your machine, such as C:\pwnedpasswords.

3. Download Crypto++ to your machine as well (for this test I used version 6.1.0). Unzip it to a folder on your machine, such as C:\crypto.

4. Open Visual Studio, and open C:\crypto\cryptest.sln. You may be prompted to install some missing features. Click Install. At the top of the Visual Studio window, ensure Debug and Win32 are selected.

5. From the Build menu, choose Batch Build. From the selections in the next pop-up box, choose:

• cryptlib / Debug / x64
• cryptlib / Release / x64

Then click Build.

6. Now open C:\pwnedpasswords\PwnedPasswordsDLL.sln. At the top of the Visual Studio window, ensure Release and x64 are selected.

7. Download Troy Hunt's 500M Pwned Passwords from here. Extract the .7z file to a central location, such as \\yourdomain.local\passwords.

8. Open C:\pwnedpasswords\PwnedPasswordsDLL\dllmain.cpp and search for a section that looks like this:

// String array of the file names + locations - you may customise if you wish
string str1[3] = { "C:\\pwned-passwords-1.0.txt", "C:\\pwned-passwords-update-1.txt", "C:\\pwned-passwords-update-2.txt" };

You can edit these three paths to be various password files of your choosing. For example, you can change C:\\pwned-passwords-1.0.txt to be the UNC path you established in step 7. Remember that in the code, you need to use double slashes for each slash, so using the example in step 7, you'd want the path to look like \\\\yourdomain.local\passwords.

Then you can leave the other two paths as is, or create a file of SHA-1 hashes of your choosing to help verify the password checks are working. For example, I created a file called C:\brianspasswords.txt and then used an online SHA-1 generator to make a hash of a verify specific password, such as IsPwnedPasswordsW0rking?, which results in a string of 0C83240100274C96976E4C62AE67C959531048F7. So to test this specific password out, I put the SHA-1 hash into C:\brianspasswords.txt and then changed the C:\\pwned-passwords-update-1.txt path to point to brianspasswords.txt

9. In Visual Studio click Project -> PwnedPasswordsDLL Properties... and make these changes:

• Configuration Properties -> VC++ Directories -> Include Directories - do a right-click on the path and click Edit, then add C:\crypto and click OK.
• Configuration Properties -> VC++ Directories -> Library Directories - do a right-click on the path and click Edit and then insert the path C:\crypto\x64\Output\Debug\ and click OK.
• Configuration Properties -> Linker -> Input -> Additional Dependencies - do a right-click on the path and click Edit and then insert the path C:\crypto\x64\Output\Debug\cryptlib.lib and click OK.
• Configuration Properties -> C/C++ -> Code Generation -> Runtime Library - change to Multi-threaded Debug (/MTd)

10. In Visual Studio click Build - > Build Solution

11. Take the compiled DLL from C:\pwnedpasswords\PwnedPasswordsDLL\x64\release\PwnedPasswordsDLL.dll and copy it to the C:\windows\system32 directory of your domain controllers.

12. In the registry for each DC, open up HKLM\System\CurrentControlSet\Control\Lsa\Notification packages.

13. There will likely be an existing entry that looks like:

scecli
rassfm

Add PwnedPasswordsDLL (just the DLL name without the extension) so that the finished entry looks like this:

scecli
rassfm
PwnedPasswordsDLL

14. Reboot all domain controllers.

15. From a test client machine, reboot the machine and log back in.

16. Hit Ctrl+Alt+Del and choose to change your password.

17. Attempt to change the password to the specific test password you selected in step 8. You should receive a message that the password does not meet the complexity requirements established by the domain policy.

Troubleshooting

No matter what password I pick, Windows says it doesn't meet the requirements for the domain password policy Check your password policy for the Minimum password age setting. If this is set to 1 and you've recently been resetting test users in AD, they may not have the ability to change their own password at all (until 24 hours pass). You can change this setting to 0 to allow immediate password changes.

What if I want to do a slow rollout/test phase without installing this on all DCs? You could put the DLL on just one DC, for example, then follow an article like this one which will let you point a test machine at a specific DC for authentication so you can test the DLL before rolling out to other DCs.

---

Option 2: SafePass.me

SafePass.me is a commercial solution (~$700) that integrates Troy Hunt's Pwned Passwords project via a Microsoft MSI file.

1. Download the SafePass trial evaluation here

2. Run the .MSI file as administrator. You'll be prompted to reboot to make the config changes take place.

3. Reboot the domain controller, and the password check is now active (you can verify this in HKLM\System\CurrentControlSet\Control\Lsa\Notification packages - there will be a SafePassMe entry).

4. On the DC, you can open c:\windows\system32\safepassme\wordlist.txt and add any custom words you don't want users to use. This can be things like your company name, domain name, etc.

5. On a client machine, attempt to change a user passwords to one in the Pwned Passwords list or in the wordlist.txt. You should get the message saying that the password does not meet complexity requirements.

6. On the DC, open Event Viewer and look in the Security log - you should see events from source SafePassMe that indicate whether the password was successfully allowed or not.

7. Should you need to disable SafePassMe, open HKLM\System\CurrentControlSet\Control\Lsa\Notification packages, remove the SafePassMe entry and reboot the DC(s).

---

Option 3: Pwned Passwords API

With this option, you download DLL and install it on all domain controllers. Essentially the process is the same as the DLL option above. Stick the DLL in C:\Windows\System32 and open the HKLM\System\CurrentControlSet\Control\Lsa\Notification packages key and add the line PwnedPasswordsDLL-API. Reboot.

When people change their password, the first five characters of it will be send via the public API. For example, if you tried to change your password to P@ssw0rd, the first five characters of the password hash is 21BD1, so an API call would go out with those characters and return all hashes that start with 21BD1. Then your local machine checks the full hash against all the matches that start with 21BD1 and either allow or forbid the password.

Pwned Passwords vs. Safepass.me - feature comparison table

	PwnedPasswordsDLL	SafePass.Me	Pwned Passwords API
Price	Free	Paid - check SafePass.me	Free
Install difficulty	Moderate (requires you to build a DLL)	Easy (.MSI installer)	Easy
Supports custom wordlists	Yes (SHA1 format)	Yes (plain text)	No
Open source	Yes	No	Yes
Support included	No - just through GitHub/blog posts	Yes	No - just through GitHub/blog posts
All password checks done offline	Yes	Yes	No
Disk space requirements	~30GB for PwnedPassword database	~500MB	A few KB

Creating customized wordlists

Since the PwnedPasswords DLL option allows you (at least) 3 password file "slots," you could throw Troy's list in one, and then make custom lists for slots 2 or 3. Here's an approach I've used for a few customers to make a custom list that aims to avoid any mention of their company name:

1. In Kali, use a tool like CeWL (https://github.com/digininja/CeWL) to create a custom wordlist. For example, you could scrape a lot of keywords off a public Web site like so:

cewl.rb -d 2 -m 7 -w 7ms.us.txt https://7minsec.com -v

How this breaks down is:

• -d is the level of links deep the tool will crawl
• -m is the minimum character length of words that will be grabbed
• -w indicates an output file
• -v is verbose

2. Once the wordlist is captured, you can "mangle" it using rsmangler (https://github.com/digininja/RSMangler) like so:

/opt/rsmangler/rsmangler.rb --file 7ms.txt > 7ms-mangled.txt

• --file tells rsmangler what wordlist to use
• > 7ms-mangled.txt tells rsmangler to save the tool output into a specific file

3. You need to convert all the plain text words in 7ms-mangled.txt to SHA1, which can be done using hashblade (https://github.com/WalderlanSena/hashblade) like so:

hashblade -list -sha1 7ms-mangled.txt > 7ms-mangled-sha1.txt

• -sha1 tells hashblade which hash function to use
• > 7ms-mangled-sha1.txt tells hashblade to save the tool output to a specific file

4. Use this to clean up hashblade output so it contains only hashes:

sed 's/Sha1 >>> //g' 7ms-mangled-sha1.txt > 7ms-custom1.txt

5. Move 7ms-custom1.txt to C:\ (or save it as C:\7mscustom2.txt). The domain controller will immediately start checking any future password changes against these two files.

Creating wordlists that contain a minimum amount of characters

One of my customers wanted to only have passwords in the PwnedPasswords list that were 12 characters or greater (to keep the text file to a manageable size).

I grabbed the plain text version of Pwned Passwords, and then ran

$data = get-content ".\big-list-o-passwords.txt"
$amount = 12;
$y= @()
foreach($line in $data)
{
   if ( $line.length -gt 1){ $y += $line.substring(0,$amount) }
}
$y | Out-File .\12-or-more.txt